Hey, TV viewer! When I'm not discussing TV on this site, you can find me doing daily TV updates on Facebook and Tumblr. You can also follow me on Twitter. I'm on these social sites talking TV all day, all the time!

23 March 2006

My American Idol Score Card - Top 11

I wasn't expecting 50's week to be a good show. I personally don't dig 50's music, nor the 50's era. I was expecting to be bored and detached. But I have to agree with Paula Abdul when she said that last night was one of the best. I'm neither drunk nor high on something, I just happen to see what she also saw. I enjoyed this one. I never would have thought I would enjoy it. It truly was one of the best "episodes" on Americal Idol. I'd even dare say that this batch is probably the best (alright, second best to Season 1) I've seen on AI.


Rating Legends:

PERFORMANCE
- includes stage presence, camera flirtation, projection, audience impact, movements or choreography, dramatic impact

VOCALS
- exactly what it is: VOICE
- "If I close my eyes and listen, do they still sound as good?"

STYLE
- includes the physical appeal, personaly style, looks, how they carry themselves, how they carry their clothes (if it is right for their age/performance/personality)

50's Week


  • MANDISA
    Performance - 8
    Vocals - 7.5
    Style - 8.5

    Total - 8

    **********

  • BUCKY
    Performance - 6
    Vocals - 7
    Style 6.5

    Total - 6.5

    **********

  • PARIS
    Performance - 7
    Vocals - 7
    Style - 8

    Total - 7.33


    **********


  • CHRIS
    Performance - 10
    Vocals - 7.5
    Style - 10

    Total - 9.16

    **********

  • KATHARINE
    Performance- 7.5
    Vocals - 7.5
    Style - 8

    Total - 7.66

    **********

  • TAYLOR
    Performance - 8.5
    Vocals - 8
    Style - 7.5

    Total 8

    **********

  • LISA
    Performance - 7
    Vocals - 6
    Style - 6

    Total - 6.33


    **********

  • KEVIN
    Performance - 6
    Vocals - 7
    Style - 6

    Total - 6.33

    **********

  • ELLIOT
    Performance - 7
    Vocals - 9
    Style - 6.6

    Total - 7.5


    **********

  • KELLIE
    Performance - 7
    Vocals - 7
    Style - 7

    Total - 7


    **********


  • ACE
    Performance - 6
    Vocals - 6
    Style - 6

    Total - 6

    RUNDOWN OF TOTALS


    Chris - 9.16
    Taylor - 8
    Mandisa - 8
    Katharine - 7.66
    Elliot - 7.5
    Paris - 7.33
    Kellie - 7
    Bucky - 6.5
    Lisa- 6.33
    Kevin - 6.33
    Ace- 6


    * Interesting to note that even if I saw this as one of the best episodes, my score card was actually higher last week. It may be because, from my perpective, the playing field was even-ed out last night. The "bad" singers got better and the "good" singers, except for one, didn't reach for the stars.


    Actual results of bottom three:

    Lisa
    Bucky
    Kevin - Voted Off



    American Idol
    Season 5 - Top 11 Performance Round
    Original Airing: March 22, 2006
    Network: Fox
  • No comments:

    Post a Comment